Sponge Docks: Facelift or No Facelift?
Updates to a planned makeover for the Tarpon Springs sponge docks, including a new conceptual design from Hoffman Architects, were presented at Tuesday night's Board of Commissioners meeting. What do you think?
Ask Tarpon Springs City Manager Mark LeCouris his response to the most recent potential design for the sponge docks, and he sums it up this way: "At least we've gone from Disneyland to modern."
The last time Hoffman Architects presented a concept for the sponge docks, the result was anything but magical.
Merchants and residents compared the ideas to the likes of Disney and other theme parks and were not on board for the changes, according to LeCouris.
“They were getting frantic,” remembered LeCouris. “So, we stepped away from the issue and went back to the drawing board.”
At Tuesday night's City Commission meeting, the response was more positive.
During the public comment portion of the meeting, residents and merchants commended principal architect Edward C. Hoffman and company for taking their wishes into consideration with the revamped design.
It was through multiple public workshops that Hoffman and his team were able to receive and consider feedback from residents and merchants.
A Tarponite himself, Hoffman pointed out that he wants the same things as so many others, which include improving the docks while keeping the rich history in place.
Hoffman presented eight additions on Tuesday:
- Element 1: an amphitheater and dock expansion directly across from the Sponge Exchange
- Element 2: a river-walk of connecting docks that would offer a different perspective of the sponge docks for pedestrians
- Element 3: observation platforms that rise above the area for a birds-eye view of the sponge docks
- Element 4: floating docks for kayakers and water recreation vessels
- Element 5: brick streets and landscaping to alleviate disconnect between merchants
- Element 6: an arched gateway welcoming visitors to the Tarpon Springs Sponge Docks
- Element 7: landscape parking and empty lots along Dodecanese Blvd.
- Element 8: generate walkways throughout the sponge docks
Sign up for the free Tarpon Springs Patch email newsletter to stay connected to your community.
Other, smaller elements Hoffman proposed included lighting systems, benches and shelters for shade. Signage throughout the area was the icing on the cake for the proposal.
Although members of the public were more content with the current proposal than previous ones, there was still a sense of a desire to keep things the same.
"My business is located in a 100-year-old building, and my customers get so excited when they come in," Athena Tsardoulias said during public comment. "They say, 'This is it, this is why I came here, this is the real Tarpon.' "
Tsardoulias wasn't completely against the new design but wanted to be sure that certain historical elements would be preserved.
So What Will it Cost?
On the other side of the issue, Commissioner Townsend Tarapani voiced concern over what the city's budget would actually cover.
Currently, $1.3 million has been designated for a facelift on the sponge docks through the Penny for Pinellas program.
"If you spend $1.3 million in the middle of the sponge docks and nothing on either side of that center portion changes, to me, that's going to look a little awkward," Tarapani said.
LeCouris responded to Tarapani with an idea of focusing on element one, the amphitheater, first and then adjusting the addition so that other "extras" would still be in reach, like signage or lighting.
Hoffman declined to discuss exact numbers during the meeting.
Tarpon Springs Mayor David O. Archie added that the project is just an option among many the city can undertake with the $1.3 million.
"The easiest thing to do, as a party up here, is to do nothing," Mayor Archie said.
He added that his main concern with the new design was similar to Commissioner Tarapani's: bang for the buck.
"What type of finished product will we get for the $1.3 million?" Mayor Archie said. "To me, when everything is said and done, that's the bottom line."
Take a virtual tour of the updated design by clicking here: Animation of Proposed Conceptual Design.
What do you think of the new design, Tarpon Springs? We want to hear from you, so leave your feedback in the comments section below.
David Bolton Realtor
8:07 am on Thursday, February 21, 2013
I think making some changes are a great idea! Making the water more accessible is huge for todays active life style of residents and visitors. I spend a great amount of time in other areas of the county and with visitors to Tarpon. Most often I hear that the Sponge Docs are a trip everyone should take at least once. I would like to see it become more of a destination location and these kind of changes are what is needed. Building owners that think people want to see run down, junky buildings are crazy. You can maintain the history, tell the story of Tarpon and create a classy experience that vistors will come back for.
Diane Fay
9:08 am on Thursday, February 21, 2013
Is there something still in-between the newest plan, and what is now??? I'm not feeling the character that ONLY belongs to the sponge docks!!
Jim Bouldin
9:25 am on Thursday, February 21, 2013
I have two primary thoughts on this project. First, I do agree with our Commissioners who expressed firm opinions concerning the "bang for the buck" we will receive after tapping an estimated $1.2 million from the Pennies for Pinellas fund. We will need to take a hard look at the work flow chart and the line item costs associated with this project in order to get a better handle on things. Secondly, I believe it is possible to add the great new features proposed in phase one of this master plan without sacrificing the historical integrity of our world famous Sponge Docks. I get a keen sense from all concerned that a great deal of caution as to how to stay "true" to the original essence of the Docks has been exercised throughout the planning stage - now we must monitor the effort as we enter into the execution phase to ensure we achieve a satisfactory final result.
Mary M.
5:38 pm on Thursday, February 21, 2013
The Sponge Docks are a "draw" for people to come and spend some quality time with their families. It needs to get a "facelift". It's such a pretty area but change is good and profitable. You need to spend a little to make a little.....Go for it. It will bring a good crowd of people with something new and updated. It will bring jobs,increase profits for the stores/restaurants,and draw people from other areas to the great "Tarpon Springs". We need this.........remember change is good!
Tommy Frain
10:48 pm on Thursday, February 21, 2013
We must maintain the historical nature of the Docks, but we must modernize with times and attract more people to the area. On the campaign trail, I have talked to many of the Dock merchants, and they are all hurting. I think the plans are reasonable and will payoff in the end when we see a finished product and more business for the Sponge Docks merchants.
Rachel Jolley
8:43 am on Friday, February 22, 2013
Thank you all for reading and sharing your perspectives on Tarpon Springs Patch!
vlk
8:07 pm on Saturday, February 23, 2013
I do like the idea of updating the Docks & keeping the historical nature. I would like to see docking access for tri-county boaters so that they can to putt-putt in for a day's visit, have lunch, shop around and then putt back home Maybe is this the purpose of Element 4? I believe this is "a good bang for our buck idea".I don't see the difference between Elements 5&8, they appear the same to me. I don't agree with •Element 6: an arched gateway welcoming visitors to the Tarpon Springs Sponge Docks- too Disney like. Also, some of the shops are so dusty and dirty that I won't go in them, so they need to be cleaned up. I think we are getting there with some better idea's using the "Kiss method" of Keeping it Simple.
michael mirra
10:31 am on Sunday, February 24, 2013
The arched Gateway is a good take off of Fisherman's wharf in San Francisco that makes it nationally recognizable. If it gets enough national attention, people will travel to the area with the idea of a MUST do of seeing the fabled Sponge Docks of Tarpon Springs. The association of image with fisherman's wharf would put the sponge docks on an instantly higher level & make Tarpon Springs well known all over the country.
Richy Vaughan
7:49 am on Sunday, February 24, 2013
An Ampitheater.... what a terrific idea. Can we consider that some day we will see productions of the great Greek works? ster
America's Disaster Relief
8:02 pm on Tuesday, February 26, 2013
What ever is done KEEP THE GREEK and the old lockers of the past, the smells of the sponges - EVERYTHING should be kept GREEK that is what is special about Tarpon Springs - the people, the culture. PLEASE don't lose it.